32 Comments

A lot in this article, thanks for it. I think that the committee did the right thing by leaving FSU out of the playoffs, and subsequent events proved them to be unequivocally correct.

Expand full comment

You started the article quite articulate and unbiased. However, when you went to, “While culturally they may be more of an ASU-type party school, their football team is devotedly followed by non-college educated, Walmart-type fans; just like USC.”, you showed yourself to be nothing more than what you accuse. You are not a football observer, as you claim, you are nothing more than an ignorant, uneducated, Walgreens (I.e., not good enough for Walmart) shopper. This is from a true football observer who is an SEC fan, not a fan of either team being discussed by you.

Expand full comment
author

Oh, how thankful and lucky I am to be blessed by the presence of a true football observer who is an SEC fan. You did a great job of showing that I am exactly "what you accuse", a non-college educated Walmart-type fan (of California, no less). You really burned me there, a very elegant "no u" indeed. Top marks!

Expand full comment

Christopher Helling--I'm not here to attack this entire piece, because as an avid Cal fan I appreciate the diligence of your analysis both here and before past games. Insults removed, however, Jon has a point.

As a "college-educated" alumnus of both Cal and FSU, a fan of both football teams, and as someone who has spent equal time in both Berkeley and Tallahassee, I say that it was ignorant and elitist to cherry-pick an entire fanbase for the most negative stereotypes and examples you could find. You speculate that FSU is "more of an ASU-type party school, their football team is devotedly followed by non-college educated." You assert that FSU is guilty of "over a decade of being a monetary drain on the conference with their football incompetence."

Seriously, how would even you know? Have you ever even been to FSU, Tallahassee, or a game at Doak? Or did you assert that stereotype by looking at shots of the FSU crowd when you reviewed past game footage?

What's more, you do realize that FSU won the last National Championship of the BCS era just ten years ago in January 2014, right? You also realize that despite having some sub-par seasons recently, FSU las largely led the ACC in viewership ratings? Hardly a "monetary drain."

The arrogance among the FSU fanbase was palpable this past summer. It pissed me off to no end that the FSU talking heads have continued to dismiss and disrespect Cal. I hope Cal rolls in there this weekend and makes a statement. But, we don't do ourselves any favors by sinking to that level.

Expand full comment

At some point, fan blogs are allowed to be fan blogs. Cal fans could go out and collect receipts for everything that's been said about us, but we don't -- because it's all fun and games.

Expand full comment

Tell that to the author of this article.

Expand full comment

You missed my point -- you're taking this too seriously.

Expand full comment

I didn't miss your point. I just disagree. It's one thing to laugh at FSU fans for their terrible start to the season. It's another thing to make classist and elitist comments.

Expand full comment
author

Really, Jon has a point? And what point is that? That he was easily baited by the part of the article meant specifically to incite FSU fans? And furthermore, are you really going to argue that FSU is NOT a party school?

Yes, obviously I'm aware of FSU's BCS National Championship, hence why I cherry-picked their record starting after that point. Yes, I'm aware of FSU's viewership numbers and hence their value to the ACC's television contract. The point of the article is not to seriously examine media contract rights. The point of that part of the article is to annoy FSU fans, because obviously you'd be offended by being reminded of your mediocre record despite the huge investment into the football program. And are you new to these articles? I grew up in LA and have a lot of friends who went to UCLA. I am still going to trash UCLA in the previews every time we play them. The same goes to USC or Auburn or any other school that takes themselves way too seriously. 8% of the views on the Auburn article were linked from their message board. I enjoy the engagement, and having fans of Auburn or FSU or whoever show up and talk trash. The fact that this needs to be explained, or the fact that you'd try and defend an exceedingly dumb comment is kind of embarrassing. As Rob said, lighten up.

The FSU administration very much played a part in jeopardizing Cal football's ability to stay solvent and compete at the power conference level, so yes, my distaste the FSU administration is very much real. My only regret about this article was not going harder at them.

Expand full comment

Jon has a point that your comment showed the same ignorance that you imply FSU fans have. Yes, he was easily baited. But I don't think your comment was bait, or a joke, or just having fun like Rob says. It's easy for you to point to that in retrospect and act like people who took it seriously are just easily offended. But you crossed the line.

Look, you can rip on FSU all you want. I'll be the first to tell you it's deserved. I already mentioned how much their elitism and arrogance has pissed me off even as an alumnus. And, I completely agree with you about FSU's role in jeopardizing Cal football's ability to compete at the highest level. But my point is that your comment was elitist and unrelated to football. From your lofty Californian tower you took a shot at people who live in or near Tallahassee and support FSU, insinuating that they are poor ("Walmart-type") and uneducated. Once again, how would you know?

You trashing UCLA is not the same thing, since you grew up in that demographic. But trashing a demographic that you know nothing about with disparaging comments? That's just ignorant and as you say, embarrassing.

Expand full comment
author

I believe Chris's comments are not directed at Florida State students or alumni, but the surrounding infamous hangers on fanbase that has a pretty poor reputation in the college football world. I have enjoyed pretty good interactions with the former and pretty poor ones with the latter. However in pieces such as these that are already content dense, it is difficult to also make those sociological distinctions when dropping barbs.

Expand full comment
author

This is absolutely it, thank you for helping to clarify. The exact words I wrote, since apparently we're litigating my articles all of a sudden, was "their football team is devotedly followed by non-college educated, Walmart-type fans; just like USC." At no point was I saying anything about FSU students or alums, or that all FSU fans are trailer trash Walmart folks or anything like that; just that their fanbase happens to extend well beyond the alumni base into groups like this. It's also pretty well-known that these sorts of fans are also not the most well-mannered group-- or did I not go far enough in documenting enough racial incidents that have happened recently? That's not a "classist" or "elitist" take at all.

Expand full comment
author

Also, I'm glad that Jon was so offended by being compared to USC that he felt compelled to leave a stupid comment. He should be offended, being compared to USC was an insult.

Expand full comment
author

It’s a preview article having fun man. Lighten up.

Expand full comment

USC catching strays, and I’m here for it!

Expand full comment

All that talk about racism at FSU has me terrified as I'll be there this weekend :(

Expand full comment

Wait, I didn't know Washington went into college playoffs last year undefeated. I must have not cared at all

Expand full comment
Sep 19Liked by BentPawn

I would like to propose “Battle for the Peace Pipe” as the name of this rivalry going forward

Expand full comment

Soes anyone know the status of Reese, Vatikani, McDonald, Correia, and Miller?

Expand full comment

FSU Offense has more drops than the Berkeley Optometry Center

Expand full comment

?

Expand full comment

eye drops lol

Expand full comment

OOooohhh.

Expand full comment

It was almost painful to watch the Memphis game. Finally get a receiver open just for the receiver to drop the pass.

Expand full comment

Yes, reminds me of Modster, when Chase was injured. His passes were in the receivers' hands but, often, dropped like their were hot lava.

Expand full comment

Go Bears. Pressure the hell out of "Ugi". Load the box.. You've got the best DB's as a group in the ACC or more.

Expand full comment

I was sort of hoping that this entire article would be about the ways in which FSU is offensive, not their football team’s offense.

Expand full comment
Sep 19Liked by Christopher Helling

I can understand how the first 25 paragraphs of this article might not be enough on that topic.

Expand full comment

Go Bears! Beat FSU! On ESPN2! The nation will be watching. This is the year.

Expand full comment

So, will Sirmon take note of previous FSU games and load the box? Will he blitz? Or will he let DJ look like a Heisman candidate again? There should be no failure by Cal's defense this week. There is too much film on what worked the previous 3 weeks.

Go Bears!!

Expand full comment

It will be ironic and amusing if CAL has a more successful season than FSU and as a result gets a bigger payout than FSU as a result of rewarding success.

Expand full comment
Sep 19Liked by Christopher Helling

That would be a terrific outcome. I also wonder if we could renegotiate the GOR monies due to our success and meme profile we seem to have developed. We seem to be an asset to the ACC rather than merely the 17th best team in the conference.

Expand full comment