Well you said it again, Nick. Thanks for your sober thoughts that Stanford is our last genuine hope for a W this season and it’s iffy at that. But I’m such an Old Blue that I’ll still watch games, wear my Cal gear all day, and savor my guacamole, while texting cross country laments with Uncle Sam.
Cal’s football season ended a long time ago, and it still tries to figure out how to win the games it lost to both better and worse opponents. It is a sad, sorry state of affairs, team, that my face buries itself in the ground every game on Saturdays.
Great analysis Nick. The only quibble I have with you is I don't even care about the "Little Game" with FURD anymore, as the two programs are the worst in the P4. I'm embarrassed when I'm talking to my Non-Cal friends now, because even the ACC analysts (who are paid to pump up the ACC) are talking trash (actually truth) about the sad state of Cal football. If buyout is on the table, let's do that and start over again and put our NIL $$ into OL and DL.
I'm really conflicted about this because there's no good solution here. I think strong offensive/defensive lines are absolutely the key to a successful football team, but I don't think you can just buy one from the portal, as good/great linemen don't grow on trees. Last year's transfer portal had two 5-star OL and 21 4-star OL. The 2027 HS recruits have five 5-star OL and 54 4-star OL. Even if money is no object and we're suddenly able to outbid all the other blue chip programs competing for these same top OL recruits, you still need an entire unit of them (having Penei Sewell on one side of the line doesn't matter if you have a traffic cone on the other side of it), and they need to work well as a unit (having the biggest, toughest guys on the line doesn't matter if they can never figure out their assignments or who's responsible for the blitz or stunting defender, etc). Even if you had A+ talent on the lines, they still need coaching and time to develop together as a unit to be effective (HS recruits also usually need a lot of time to close the physical gap between HS/college). This is also overly simplifying things anyway-- I am afraid that our coaching staff may just be chasing stars, while there's plenty of programs out there (e.g. Utah) that have historically managed to find and develop plenty of 3-star OL/DL into top NFL prospects.
In my view, the best way to build solid lines would be a steady pipeline of line talent (for a couple of years, at least), as well as the coaching to develop those players. While I think Tosh may be able to handle the former, I'm overwhelmingly convinced that we do not have the latter. While Hutchings has had flashes of promise (in no small part to having an absolute NFL-caliber freak in Lopa) and I could conceivably forgive someone for believing we might still improve there, I'm completely out on the offensive side of the ball. I think Cal does actually have NFL talent on the offense, but even if you gave the offense a full roster of it, I'm still not convinced we could do much with it. Even if you want to throw away the entire coaching staff and start over, I don't even see who you could plausibly hire that could make an impact in year one (and keep in mind, they'd be starting from scratch with recruits as well). Tosh is uniquely positioned to help Cal bring in high-level talent, but it's not going to mean much if we can't do anything with that talent.
I hear you, but we have to start somewhere - and this year's strategy of investing in skill players has panned out horribly. At least putting out the intention that Cal is the place where we are building OL and DL NFL talent would make a difference. Maybe Tosh can still recruit - but we need experienced O and D coordinators in 2027 if we keep Tosh. Plus we need to add stud coaches for OL and DL too. I'm ok with Rockfights in 2027, even if we only break even on them and go something like 6-6. I just can't take the combination of the Wilcox Offense and the Dykes Defense again in 2027, as this is too painful to watch... What Tosh has going for him in 2027 is that he can promise many HS recruits that they will get to play immediately, as the portal is going to be absolutely BRUTAL and CRUSHING at the end of this season...
are there any good OL coaches or offensive coordinators we can hire who will bring 3-4 OL players with them? UCLA basically did this, but with a head coach hire. I don't see any other way to quickly improve our OL
Excellent analysis. Ingrassia would have been more effective if they had him pass the second or third time in. As the color commentator said "He is a quarterback, after all." But if he was effective passing AND running he might show up the NFL Prospect who is a very one dimensional long ball pocket passer who doesn't have a pocket.
Why are they not using Rolo? Is Lupoi too scared if Rolo does good, he’ll get pushed aside for him?? Only thing I can think of. But the games are embarrassing and no fun to even watch. I left the last home game shortly after the first half, then turned off the game this past weekend same. I never do that. It used to be that the trouble with Cal was what seemed like a curse that the game was never won/lost till there was 0 on the clock, but that isn’t even happening. Looks like bad high school team playing…makes me sick to see Lupoi destroy Cal football and we seriously have to stick with him?? There has to be a way that smart Cal grads can figure out to get rid of him. Because this is bad, very bad…
Rolo!Rolo!Rolo! Jeri, I'm not sure that even Rolo can save the sinking ship that is Cal Football but considering how desperate we are, anything is worth a try.
"I had a dream my life would be So different from this hell I'm living, So different now from what it seemed... Now life has killed the dream I dreamed.." -- Fantine, Les Miz
Nick: The only thought going through my head about Cal Football since Saturday is this: WE ARE ABSOLUTELY FUCKED!!!! I should use another adjective since this is a family website but I can't think of anything more positive to say. I suppose that, instead of being the second coming of DeShawn Foster, Tosh could actually be the second coming of Sonny Dykes. Like Tosh, Dykes had a horrendous first year (1-11) which was followed by a bad but improving year (5-7) which was then followed by a winning year (7-5) and winning the now defunct Redbox Bowl (aka, the "Granddaddy of them all") to finish at 8-5. As your article pointed out, we are stuck with Tosh until at least year three and if things don't improve, THEN we can show him the door. But three years is a long time to wait for 7-5. In the meantime, Bob Chesney and FUCLA will be building a football and athletic brand worth watching, thus attracting more eyeballs, attention, applications, etc., and Cal will continue the long slide towards the new Pac-12. Sigh......
I don't understand how or why Cal thought replacing competent if not spectacular coaching with Tosh surrounded by no one somehow was a better idea than actually fielding an o-line, which was the biggest single factor with the last several teams that disappointed as well.
But then I also don't understand how going 2-1 to finish the season won't result in a better record than going 1-2 at the expense of the other 2 games for a home win over a team that has lost every road game by 4+ TDs.
Buy out is halved if RR goes also, right? So seems like a good option.
But we need to find a replacement for both RR and TL that we can announce in December. Do we have time for that? That’s probably the most important thing right now other than the money. It’s the planning for next year.
Questions are who has the authority to fire them both and who is going to hire their replacements? Also, don’t we have something like two other Co-Directors for our other sports?
It is the Chancellor. The structure was set up making football independent of the ADs and Rivera reports directly to the Chancellor. One hope is that the Chancellor, as someone mentioned elsewhere, is a business person and is thus very aware of the Sunk Cost Fallacy.
That was probably me or LosAltosOski. And yes, hopefully Chancellor Lyons makes a clear-eyed business decision before the end of the year. Time is of the essence - sooner the better, given the accelerated timelines for recruiting/early signing period, transfer portal, and the coaching carousel.
BTW, absolutely in no way, shape, or form should Simon-O'Neill & Larson be allowed to even touch a potential search for a replacement. They are the standard bearers for the decade-plus incompetence and institutional rot in the AD, extending back to at least the Knowlton regime & Williams tenure.
Can we get Joe Lacob to go part time? He may be for a different sport, but he clearly knows the type of intelligence and thought that is required for a head coach between the two we've seen him hire.
Can Lupoi be ‘reassigned’ under Rivera but kept on payroll as a ‘special advisor’ or something similar like ‘recruiting specialist’? Seems like a cheaper solution than a payout…. Or put him in the announcers booth because, man, those pressers..
The problem is that the team is simply not getting better as the season rolls along, it's getting worse. You would hope that all of those little mistakes that led to a loss against UCLA would get ironed out over time, but nope they're still here and maybe more prevalent than ever.
Sy: The coaching staff ABSOLUTELY SUCKS!!!!! Even the play-by-play announcers on Saturday were scratching their heads at some of the plays that Cal was running. Everybody needs to say, "Hello new Pac-12!".
Great analysis, Nick. It’s definitely a mess with little prospect of any significant change.
I also find the use of Ingrassia really strange, especially when leaving JKS standing as a statue next to the sideline. I looked Ingrassia up on the roster and here’s what it says:
Freshman (2024) - College of San Mateo
Led College of San Mateo to the 2024 California junior college state championship.
Threw for 1,590 yards and 13 touchdowns over 10 games played at CSM in 2024.
Added two rushing touchdowns for the Bulldogs in 2024.
Won a state title at San Marin High School as a junior and recorded 40 touchdown passes for a 12-1 team as a senior.
Seems like maybe there’s a better use for him!
And since we don’t have a Chuck Muncie in the backfield even with Mohammed marginally healthy, why not coach up one of the really big linemen or tight ends sitting on the bench to run straight ahead into the line on short yardage situations? They couldn’t do any worse than our current RB corps and desperate situations call for desperate measures. Size matters! If only to beat Stanford!
Your comment is reflective of the fact that Cal’s OC (whomever it might be) does not grasp the simple concept of deception, which can lead to the much needed big play, or at least 10–15 yards. Seems like. No brainer to try a direct snap to Ing, he briefly faked the run then pulls up to hit a tight end who faked the block. Or, do a pump and go on the dreaded wide receiver screens that never work because the opposing DBs sell out to crash the blockers and blow the play up before it can even start. I could go on and on. Whatever misdirection or deception the OC thinks he’s doing is not fooling anyone: they’ve read the scouting report. Fundamentally, this is why a wishbone type offense (revised) is still works for an undersized team like Navy.
Yeah i don't get keeping JKS in on these plays. get another OL to block or a TE to block (maybe? welp?) or catch? Unless there's some defensive formation that would TRIGGER JKS to come back to the backfield and Ingrassia becoming a WR, why have him out there.
Well you said it again, Nick. Thanks for your sober thoughts that Stanford is our last genuine hope for a W this season and it’s iffy at that. But I’m such an Old Blue that I’ll still watch games, wear my Cal gear all day, and savor my guacamole, while texting cross country laments with Uncle Sam.
GO BEARS! Make it a 4-9 season!!
Ditto…Go Bears!
Cal’s football season ended a long time ago, and it still tries to figure out how to win the games it lost to both better and worse opponents. It is a sad, sorry state of affairs, team, that my face buries itself in the ground every game on Saturdays.
Great analysis Nick. The only quibble I have with you is I don't even care about the "Little Game" with FURD anymore, as the two programs are the worst in the P4. I'm embarrassed when I'm talking to my Non-Cal friends now, because even the ACC analysts (who are paid to pump up the ACC) are talking trash (actually truth) about the sad state of Cal football. If buyout is on the table, let's do that and start over again and put our NIL $$ into OL and DL.
I'm really conflicted about this because there's no good solution here. I think strong offensive/defensive lines are absolutely the key to a successful football team, but I don't think you can just buy one from the portal, as good/great linemen don't grow on trees. Last year's transfer portal had two 5-star OL and 21 4-star OL. The 2027 HS recruits have five 5-star OL and 54 4-star OL. Even if money is no object and we're suddenly able to outbid all the other blue chip programs competing for these same top OL recruits, you still need an entire unit of them (having Penei Sewell on one side of the line doesn't matter if you have a traffic cone on the other side of it), and they need to work well as a unit (having the biggest, toughest guys on the line doesn't matter if they can never figure out their assignments or who's responsible for the blitz or stunting defender, etc). Even if you had A+ talent on the lines, they still need coaching and time to develop together as a unit to be effective (HS recruits also usually need a lot of time to close the physical gap between HS/college). This is also overly simplifying things anyway-- I am afraid that our coaching staff may just be chasing stars, while there's plenty of programs out there (e.g. Utah) that have historically managed to find and develop plenty of 3-star OL/DL into top NFL prospects.
In my view, the best way to build solid lines would be a steady pipeline of line talent (for a couple of years, at least), as well as the coaching to develop those players. While I think Tosh may be able to handle the former, I'm overwhelmingly convinced that we do not have the latter. While Hutchings has had flashes of promise (in no small part to having an absolute NFL-caliber freak in Lopa) and I could conceivably forgive someone for believing we might still improve there, I'm completely out on the offensive side of the ball. I think Cal does actually have NFL talent on the offense, but even if you gave the offense a full roster of it, I'm still not convinced we could do much with it. Even if you want to throw away the entire coaching staff and start over, I don't even see who you could plausibly hire that could make an impact in year one (and keep in mind, they'd be starting from scratch with recruits as well). Tosh is uniquely positioned to help Cal bring in high-level talent, but it's not going to mean much if we can't do anything with that talent.
I hear you, but we have to start somewhere - and this year's strategy of investing in skill players has panned out horribly. At least putting out the intention that Cal is the place where we are building OL and DL NFL talent would make a difference. Maybe Tosh can still recruit - but we need experienced O and D coordinators in 2027 if we keep Tosh. Plus we need to add stud coaches for OL and DL too. I'm ok with Rockfights in 2027, even if we only break even on them and go something like 6-6. I just can't take the combination of the Wilcox Offense and the Dykes Defense again in 2027, as this is too painful to watch... What Tosh has going for him in 2027 is that he can promise many HS recruits that they will get to play immediately, as the portal is going to be absolutely BRUTAL and CRUSHING at the end of this season...
are there any good OL coaches or offensive coordinators we can hire who will bring 3-4 OL players with them? UCLA basically did this, but with a head coach hire. I don't see any other way to quickly improve our OL
Excellent analysis. Ingrassia would have been more effective if they had him pass the second or third time in. As the color commentator said "He is a quarterback, after all." But if he was effective passing AND running he might show up the NFL Prospect who is a very one dimensional long ball pocket passer who doesn't have a pocket.
Yeah, but doesn’t matter at all. What matter is whether meathead is the HC or not.
Why are they not using Rolo? Is Lupoi too scared if Rolo does good, he’ll get pushed aside for him?? Only thing I can think of. But the games are embarrassing and no fun to even watch. I left the last home game shortly after the first half, then turned off the game this past weekend same. I never do that. It used to be that the trouble with Cal was what seemed like a curse that the game was never won/lost till there was 0 on the clock, but that isn’t even happening. Looks like bad high school team playing…makes me sick to see Lupoi destroy Cal football and we seriously have to stick with him?? There has to be a way that smart Cal grads can figure out to get rid of him. Because this is bad, very bad…
Rolo!Rolo!Rolo! Jeri, I'm not sure that even Rolo can save the sinking ship that is Cal Football but considering how desperate we are, anything is worth a try.
Bear19
"I had a dream my life would be So different from this hell I'm living, So different now from what it seemed... Now life has killed the dream I dreamed.." -- Fantine, Les Miz
Cal Football, as described by Fantine in Les Miz.
Nick: The only thought going through my head about Cal Football since Saturday is this: WE ARE ABSOLUTELY FUCKED!!!! I should use another adjective since this is a family website but I can't think of anything more positive to say. I suppose that, instead of being the second coming of DeShawn Foster, Tosh could actually be the second coming of Sonny Dykes. Like Tosh, Dykes had a horrendous first year (1-11) which was followed by a bad but improving year (5-7) which was then followed by a winning year (7-5) and winning the now defunct Redbox Bowl (aka, the "Granddaddy of them all") to finish at 8-5. As your article pointed out, we are stuck with Tosh until at least year three and if things don't improve, THEN we can show him the door. But three years is a long time to wait for 7-5. In the meantime, Bob Chesney and FUCLA will be building a football and athletic brand worth watching, thus attracting more eyeballs, attention, applications, etc., and Cal will continue the long slide towards the new Pac-12. Sigh......
There are ways to minimize the friction/cost but you absolutely have to have a suite of pros at this in the room.
Thanks Nick.
#HireWilcox
;-)
I've been waiting for that Wilcox # theme.
I don't understand how or why Cal thought replacing competent if not spectacular coaching with Tosh surrounded by no one somehow was a better idea than actually fielding an o-line, which was the biggest single factor with the last several teams that disappointed as well.
But then I also don't understand how going 2-1 to finish the season won't result in a better record than going 1-2 at the expense of the other 2 games for a home win over a team that has lost every road game by 4+ TDs.
It's the O-line. Every game they get worse, ruining the rest of the team.
Buy out is halved if RR goes also, right? So seems like a good option.
But we need to find a replacement for both RR and TL that we can announce in December. Do we have time for that? That’s probably the most important thing right now other than the money. It’s the planning for next year.
Questions are who has the authority to fire them both and who is going to hire their replacements? Also, don’t we have something like two other Co-Directors for our other sports?
We have co-ADs for other sports. They can probably run an effective search.
I don’t know who has firing authority, but I presume that it’s the Chancellor.
It is the Chancellor. The structure was set up making football independent of the ADs and Rivera reports directly to the Chancellor. One hope is that the Chancellor, as someone mentioned elsewhere, is a business person and is thus very aware of the Sunk Cost Fallacy.
That was probably me or LosAltosOski. And yes, hopefully Chancellor Lyons makes a clear-eyed business decision before the end of the year. Time is of the essence - sooner the better, given the accelerated timelines for recruiting/early signing period, transfer portal, and the coaching carousel.
BTW, absolutely in no way, shape, or form should Simon-O'Neill & Larson be allowed to even touch a potential search for a replacement. They are the standard bearers for the decade-plus incompetence and institutional rot in the AD, extending back to at least the Knowlton regime & Williams tenure.
The Co-ADs are Larry Scott hires who are being hid in a corner.
Hmm, in that case, never mind.
Can we get Joe Lacob to go part time? He may be for a different sport, but he clearly knows the type of intelligence and thought that is required for a head coach between the two we've seen him hire.
Can Lupoi be ‘reassigned’ under Rivera but kept on payroll as a ‘special advisor’ or something similar like ‘recruiting specialist’? Seems like a cheaper solution than a payout…. Or put him in the announcers booth because, man, those pressers..
Make him a CIT - Coach in Training under Rivera.
hell nah. remember that last time Tosh was disgruntled and had a fiduciary duty to the program?
Yup this
no - why should we keep him at all?
Effort and results appreciated Nick!!
I FEEL how hard it is to be a Cal fan.
I can’t imagine how difficult it must be to offer a sober recap.
Thank you!
The problem is that the team is simply not getting better as the season rolls along, it's getting worse. You would hope that all of those little mistakes that led to a loss against UCLA would get ironed out over time, but nope they're still here and maybe more prevalent than ever.
Does not speak well of the coaching staff.
Sy: The coaching staff ABSOLUTELY SUCKS!!!!! Even the play-by-play announcers on Saturday were scratching their heads at some of the plays that Cal was running. Everybody needs to say, "Hello new Pac-12!".
The picture of meathead with a smile on his face makes me want to puke.
Great analysis, Nick. It’s definitely a mess with little prospect of any significant change.
I also find the use of Ingrassia really strange, especially when leaving JKS standing as a statue next to the sideline. I looked Ingrassia up on the roster and here’s what it says:
Freshman (2024) - College of San Mateo
Led College of San Mateo to the 2024 California junior college state championship.
Threw for 1,590 yards and 13 touchdowns over 10 games played at CSM in 2024.
Added two rushing touchdowns for the Bulldogs in 2024.
Won a state title at San Marin High School as a junior and recorded 40 touchdown passes for a 12-1 team as a senior.
Seems like maybe there’s a better use for him!
And since we don’t have a Chuck Muncie in the backfield even with Mohammed marginally healthy, why not coach up one of the really big linemen or tight ends sitting on the bench to run straight ahead into the line on short yardage situations? They couldn’t do any worse than our current RB corps and desperate situations call for desperate measures. Size matters! If only to beat Stanford!
Looks like you just listed the resume of next year’s QB. Let’s hope he stays and has better coaching.
Your comment is reflective of the fact that Cal’s OC (whomever it might be) does not grasp the simple concept of deception, which can lead to the much needed big play, or at least 10–15 yards. Seems like. No brainer to try a direct snap to Ing, he briefly faked the run then pulls up to hit a tight end who faked the block. Or, do a pump and go on the dreaded wide receiver screens that never work because the opposing DBs sell out to crash the blockers and blow the play up before it can even start. I could go on and on. Whatever misdirection or deception the OC thinks he’s doing is not fooling anyone: they’ve read the scouting report. Fundamentally, this is why a wishbone type offense (revised) is still works for an undersized team like Navy.
Yeah i don't get keeping JKS in on these plays. get another OL to block or a TE to block (maybe? welp?) or catch? Unless there's some defensive formation that would TRIGGER JKS to come back to the backfield and Ingrassia becoming a WR, why have him out there.