60 Comments
User's avatar
CalBear91's avatar

It's cathartic to read others opine on the state of our team in the context of college football. I'm with those who believe that the new era is seriously problematic for fandom because it used to be we were just fans who sometimes donated, but now are expected to give deeply and often, and therefore expect professionalism from our teams. It's a quid pro quo. We pay for the team, so the team must produce. It's no surprise that not all teams will be good, and the parity created by NIL means few teams have depth. I think as Cal fans we are simultaneously quite capable of spending what the best teams can spend on a football team, and never going to sacrifice our allegiance to the academic brilliance of our university. Don't make us choose, because we will choose Nobel Prizes and academics. We are not being asked to choose, I know, but the juxtaposition of our greatness in academia always made it absurd when we sucked at football, but somehow understandable. Now that we pay huge money for our team? We expect them to be outstanding. Aye, there's the rub. We suck at football now. Really bad at football. Patience was easier when it was free.

Sandy's avatar

I enjoyed your comments and now I’m laughing. I looked up how winning seasons Cal has had since 1886. The number is 68. Then I saw a chart that listed the years. I was excited to discover that my Sophomore year was a winning season and my Freshman Junior and Senior seasons were not. I figured out I’m a graduate of an extraordinary university with a not so extraordinary football team. But we’ve had 68 winning football seasons to be proud of. So it’s on to the next game and on to next season. Go Bears💙🏈😊

Bear19's avatar

Indeed. Did you know that NIL really stands for Now It's Legal. We can't even take consolation in that SMU is paying their players, while we are not because we're pure. Go Semi-Pro Bears!

SGBear's avatar

USC outscored Cal 46-0 in the second half of their 1930 game, on the way to handing Cal their worst defeat in program history, 74-0. My point is that it has, and always can be, worse.

Bear19's avatar

I believe Tosh's great-grandfather was coaching for Cal in that game.

Blondiesandtopdog's avatar

The F is this? Seriously. An F minus and a straight F shouldn’t’ be a reason to celebrate a regular F. It’s still a fail.

If you were a Cal alum, I ask you: if you ever received an F, did you say to yourself, well, it could have been worse?

Rugbear's avatar

Ok, let's stick with modern history. ;-)

TezCalipoca's avatar

He remembers it like it was yesterday!

Clifford Fewel's avatar

At the end of the day, we are all so terribly invested in what a bunch of college kids do or don’t do. Good recap and insights, Nick.

WilderThanGene's avatar

The capitalism side of the sport has nearly destroyed itself. Tons of fanbases are unhappy with how this is going. I know its a complicated issue, but NIL and the transfer portal, in its current state, has pretty much broken the game and any sense of tradition.

I'm predicting a big backlash, and potential some major dominoes getting triggered during the next round of realignment.

If the networks will only pay big money for the big teams, tons of other current "Power 4" teams are going to be in the same position as us.

The market has said that only about 20 brands are worth something. Eventually fanbases and donor bases are going to say, what's the point anymore? Why even fight to be included in this semi pro bullsh!t league? Just go into the night, sweet bears.

TKE Prytanis 79's avatar

You've touched on something I've been thinking a lot about. I've seen so many laments on these pages that seem to assume that simply investing 25M in players should create an expectation of success. This misses the simple fact that these are the new table stakes. As you say, there are fan bases around the country screaming the same. Some form of "We gave you the money, so WTF???" (See Oregon, Texas, Michigan, Texas Tech etc, etc) Ironically, even success does not always ignite a fan base (see fUCLA). I have no idea where this all goes, other than to observe that it resembles a Stanfurd fan trying to explain themselves. I can't get my brain around it. Go Bears Forever.

wrongwaygoldfarb's avatar

Surely it's not the "money invested should amount to wins" equation that produces the laments in all fans. For me, it's that the players aren't playing at all well, the coaches aren't coaching well, the team seems to lose fundamentals and heart rapidly when faced with mounting adversity. Sure, the team's been riddled with injuries - Mohamed is REALLY missed - but dumb penalties, arm tackling, dropped passes, missed assignments: we just ain't seeing decent football being played. Hell, all I ever wanted, lo, these many years was to see the Bears compete from beginning to end. I'll never forget one game - I think the Bears were playing the Trojans during Dykes' first year - and, as a USC back was crashing into the secondary, a corner back I think just stepped aside and let him run by and score. Are we back to that kind of "football"? Is it too much to expect the players and coaches to do better than they did in the second half this last Saturday, arguably the worst half anybody can remember the Bears playing? Anyway, it's not "$$ = wins." It's "football means playing football." At least for me.

Sandy's avatar

I totally agree. It’s about playing the game as it should be played and remembering what you learned along the way before you got to college.

Clifford Fewel's avatar

I admit I'm trying hard to stay in the game. But you have said it more eloquently than I could have. All institutions have an arc.

WilderThanGene's avatar

I think what the networks and blue bloods fail to see is what will happen if the bottom drops out. Maybe for a while they can have a super league who all make huge profits for a couple years.

But what happens when the other 80% of existing College Football fans stop caring. If I want to see elite pro football, I watch the NFL.

With none of the conventional traditions (that once made the sport what it was) left to anchor the massive college football viewership at large, keeping the fanbases of the Have-Nots watching the marquee teams and matchups, like the CFP and national championship, is going to be a problem.

I'm only a fan of College Football because of Cal Football. If they get relegated, I'm not making any effort to watch other games beyond Cal Football. Sure, I'll watch a game or two here and there, almost incidentally, but the biggest consolation prize will be having my Saturdays back to do better things.

Clifford Fewel's avatar

That's how I see it. Players used to be inculcated as to traditions and their meanings by their peers from frosh through senior year. Now coach has to show a video, and even that may fade. The pros in the room are thinking about their sweet rides parked outside; meanwhile the whole building burns except the penthouse, which can stand for only so long, to your point.

AndyPanda's avatar

What the networks see and know is there are 3 kinds of fans.

Football, and especially college football, fans will and are watching games that are compelling or chaotic, regardless of who the teams are. Currently, there are more of these types of games than ever before, upsets and top vs top team games, and shootouts, and as a result, ratings are great. Also, football fans are already captured by an overall great product.

Surf by fans will stop and watch close and/or flash, and it doesn't even matter what sport it is. There are more of these than ever, AND they are the ones at play for the media. The highlight games that are in greater supply than ever capture this fleeting but valuable audience.

Team fans, such as "Cal" fans (substitute any struggling team) watch mostly or exclusively Cal (substitute team of choice)) games, regardless of how good or compelling their team is. Those fans are there for their games, almost no matter what, and as noted not much if any for any other team or game, so the media doesn't worry about losing them. Moreover, if they do lose them, there are only so many my-team-only fans of most individual teams, and if they are lost, unless it is Notre Dame, Ohio State, Texas, and the like, won't hurt much, and certainly not as much as can be gained by capturing a significant segment of surf-by fans, and retaining general football fans, both of which exist in fat greater number than fans of any given non-super power team. So the collapse is not actually coming if the overall product is kept compelling (and weekly results suggest it isn't).

Cal (team-type) fans will be on the outside looking in as long as the Cal product is not compelling, and right now, if you were to put the game in black and white (can't discern team colors) and blur/pixilate the logo, so you couldn't tell if its Cal that your are watching, would you watch just for the entertainment value seen? "Football" and surf-by fans certainly aren't and won't.

Cal (team) fan, as evidenced by comments posted, want to put a compelling product out. But its not just a matter of throwing $25K at a roster without having anyone who knows how to spend it effectively. Or addressing the myriad of other obstacles that continue to preclude sustained success. Many teams face some of those obstacles, but Cal faces almost all of them, which is why there is no quick fix that hiring a James Madison coach and his depth chart can resolve. UCLA hired one. Cal hired Tosh.

paulie's avatar

I'm already there, I only watch Cal football games now, and only if it's not the 9:30pm Central time slot.

That is a pretty big change from a few years ago when I would spend all Saturday watching games.

TKE Prytanis 79's avatar

Thanks, arcs indeed...for some reason I simply can't give voice to, I personally don't experience it as a choice about staying in the game. I will watch all the games I can, wearing my Cal stuff on game day. I will support the team in any way I can. That does not mean I will do so without anguish, criticism or disappointment at times. But they also give us such joy at times. I'm all in, forever.

Blondiesandtopdog's avatar

But is that any different than if this were a site about the Rams or the 49ers? We are invested in Cal - and football is the way that we stay connected.

All other top flight public universities are doing various degrees of excellence to middling. For us - the flagship university of the state of California- to be on the basement is embarrassing.

WilderThanGene's avatar

But we are invested in Cal only because of the tradition and history. Most fans I suspect are either Old Blues, or they became fans during the Tedford era. Both are rooted in being part of the sport when it was a different sport.

I think the same can probably be said about most programs across the country. The fan bases are rooted by something historic, or recent success.

Pro sports captured and owns the bigger regionalism and tribalism at large, and havent dramatically changed so quickly and so recently like college football.

The American tradition of pro sports already existed, under its current model, for a long time.

The NCAA model is tumultuous at best now.

GoldenBear88's avatar

Blondie: Not just embarrassing, but dangerous in the long term. Whether we like it or not, college sports draws eyeballs and attention in a way that pure academics does not. Everyone knows that Cal is a premier university but that isn't what gets people excited to donate money. I don't think that it is a coincidence that one of the driving forces in FUCLA and U$C blowing up the Pac-12 was former Fox Sports President and COO Mark Silverman, a die-hard FUCLA alum and big donor. Relegating Cal to second-tier status in football and basketball means more attention on FUCLA. I will never believe that blowing up the Pac-12 was simply about more money for football and basketball.

Blondiesandtopdog's avatar

Yes. Completely agreed. If football is relegated, UCLA will certainly become the premier public university in California. It’s already getting dangerously close as it is.

Bear19's avatar

They used to be college kids, but now they are actually semi-pro players who have no actual association with college, other than the logo on their checks.

Clifford Fewel's avatar

Is that true? No classes?

Daniel Lahl's avatar

SMU bought WF's speed boat during half time.

At least we face a team this week that is so bad they have already fired their coach - and then bad VA and Furd teams. Wait! ESPN FPI has NCSU at 70 and Cal at 91, and both UVA and Furd are 4-4.

We're looking at probably 4-8 for a team we spent $31m on this year. Who's zoomin who?

Justbear's avatar

You know what happens when we play a team that just fired their HC...

Rose Bowl Oski's avatar

Ugh... wasn't that the case with Colorado several years ago?

wrongwaygoldfarb's avatar

It was Colorado's only win that season. I remember it too well.

Justbear's avatar

Now that I think of it, I was confusing a few things. One game I had in mind was 2011 UCLA game. But then I just realized that it was that we lost to an UCLA team who had just lost to Arizona who had just fired their head coach. I remember 2011 because a high school recruit Bryce Treggs tweeted LOL to the UCLA game.

LosAltosOski's avatar

At this time I still have faith in Rich Lyons as our chancellor. I saw how he has established a clear identity, culture and alum engagement for Haas amidst top global competitions, and I know he believes in Cal Athletics excellence too.

I just don’t know how hands on he is with RR our GM.

I just hope that Tosh and companies have the right counsel to help them right this ship for the remainder of this season. They clearly need help beyond what they currently have on staff.

We have 2 years to show improvement in fan engagement and TV viewership. Few foresaw the low floor with this new coach staff. But let’s see if Tosh and companies can improve quicker as we don’t have another option right now.

Longer term - I don’t believe Cal will opt for relegation, as we have the entire athletics department that needs funding to sustain. So not improving in football seems to be out of question given the path we’ve chosen.

Rugbear's avatar

If we had 2 years we have 1.5 left. Do we continue down our current path knowing where it will lead?

GoldenBear68's avatar

“There is no way to talk about this game as anything other than another deeply disturbing datapoint under Tosh Lupoi. And what specifically scares me is the variety of bad data points.”

Thanks, Nick. Spot on analysis. And that datapoint sentence says it all. Lupoi’s strength was supposed to be defense and this team doesn’t even have that.

This has got to be one of, if not the, worst coaching performances in the history of Cal football, and there’s a lot of competition for that dubious honor.

I do not think that this HC or his assistant coaches have any idea how to get us out of the mess they have created. Yes, key injuries haven’t helped but this team has been losing games even when more of the injured have been healthy.

So, we have no running game and the OL is only marginally good for half a game at best. Our WRs can’t get consistent separation so our QB with generational talent can hit them — he clearly can hit them anywhere on the field IF they can get open and IF the OL can protect him long enough for his reads and progression.

Rafael is a great example of what Cal is likely to face again when our best players leave via the portal as soon as it opens at the end of the season and then excel on better coached teams next year.

And that of course includes JKS who would be a fool to trust his future to this coaching staff and will need a solid junior year to increase his negotiating position in the NFL draft, just like Mendoza. Apparently you can love Cal, just not play on its football team.

Blondiesandtopdog's avatar

Such a great post. Just one nit: Just because he was a DC at Oregon doesn’t necessarily mean that he was good at being a defensive mastermind. He doesn’t have a long enough track record to indicate he was any good at being a DC.

Rugbear's avatar

Just curious, does anyone still watch the interviews with Tosh? Or are you like me where you are tired of hearing the same broken record. I honestly feel bad for him but we gave him all the presents on his Christmas list and and he was pretty cocky with the preseason hype so in the end I don't have any sympathy. The guy I feel sorry for is Jaron. They should just leave him alone. There is no way he is happy with the situation and guaranteed he is gone next year, but meanwhile he has to put on the good face and pretend its all good and a learning experience.

Also, I see people on this thread saying, "do we have a right to expect success if we spend $25 or $30m on NIL?" I would respond with the following: we spent way more than $30m on NIL. We paid for a very large staff of assistant coaches as well. And there was a LOT of HYPE preseason. We fell flat our our faces.

Yeah, I'd say we have a right to expect some success. Maybe not as much as UCLA but certainly we should be better than ranked 102 (out of 138) in the ESPN poll. We are 95 places behind UCLA and I believe we have better talent. I still am pissed off that UCLA hired a coach with a track record of success and they are undefeated and are currently ranked #7 in both the AP and Coaches poll, and they look like a lock for the playoffs, and we hired a turd.

https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49868647/2026-college-football-sp+-rankings-all-138-fbs-teams

Blondiesandtopdog's avatar

I haven’t watched any of his interviews since game 1 because I got so tired of his non-substantial empty answers that masquerade as passable english. But you might already know that. I’m actually pretty curious if other people watch him.

TezCalipoca's avatar

Folks, its all going be ok. It's only math.

We beat VaTech by 5

VaTech beat GaTech by 10

GT beat Duke by 3

Duke beat the furd by 28.

So, obviously we will beat the furd by 46. That's all the matters.

J S's avatar

Ha! If only transitive victory math worked in the sports world. (If A > B and B > C, then A > C.....)

TezCalipoca's avatar

oh, and therefore we will also beat nc state by 49, since the furd clipped them by 3

justbearly's avatar

This is an expensive way to find out if a guy can be a head coach or not. Too much chaos and dysfunction. I got the big game and Pitt to go see and then the season will be over.

Old Bear 71's avatar

Nick, good thoughts, as usual, you captured my sentiments about this edition of Cal football: “?” Or “Did I just see what I think I saw?!”

On to Raleigh,

GO BEARS!

Blondiesandtopdog's avatar

Mass hallucination - great line.

KetamineCal's avatar

Did he switch coordinators at the half or something? I know that's not how it works, but we also know it literally already happened.

That 1st half was as solid as Cal has looked this year. Even reminded me of Sonny Dykes' first game with Goff.

Ken Stumpf's avatar

I think one team's staff made adjustments at the half and the other team's staff said let keep executing what we've been doing. The results were catastrophic!

Bear19's avatar

I believe immortal Pappy Waldorf once said "It's not the X's and the O's, it's the Jimmy's and the Joe's."

hoopdreams's avatar

JKS was asked what was different in the second half and he said they changed from 1 high to 2 high. I took that to mean SMU mostly played cover 1 in first half and changed to cover 2 in the second half.

I haven't gone back to watch the game again to see if that was the change, but you're saying it wasn't.

the only other theory I have is our offensive line, and our defense got tired with the travel, early morning game time and Texas heat.

With a tired offensive line JKS didn't have the time he had in the first half.

With a tired defense, we too often lost contain (usually on the outside) and didn't get the push on their rushing attack we got earlier.

A tired defense also doesn't tackle as well, as when you're tired you tend to reach and grab, instead of getting low and taking out the legs. Same thing happens when a basketball player gets tired ... their stance is no longer low, and they tend to reach instead of the more fundamental defense of moving your feet.

with injuries on both sides of the ball our lack of depth could have been the main problem in the second half

Ak_A_bear's avatar

I too pass on watching Tosh and it started to trend that way relatively early on for me. When it got into the schedule, I would click him off earlier and earlier and at the VT game I just stopped even clicking it on when it came to his press vids. Reading about was bad enough.

W. Erik Bruvold's avatar

The problem is the eyeball test. They just do NOT look well coached.