
When Cal hired Tosh Lupoi, I wrote an article titled “Tosh Lupoi will be as successful as the resources he inspires.”
The premise of the article is that I had no idea if Tosh Lupoi had the skills necessary to be a successful head coach, but I thought Cal would provide him with the financial resources to make him successful (or at least more successful than Justin Wilcox) regardless.
This, in retrospect, was very wrong.
I stand by two of the core conceits of the article:
That Cal would provide Tosh Lupoi with a level of investment that would be above average in the ACC.
That financial investment is a necessary ingredient to sustained success in college football. But while money is a necessary part of almost every* successful college football team, it is not in and of itself sufficient. You must still have a base level of competency from your coaching staff.
I maintain that the decision to hire Lupoi was a reasonable risk. Hiring a coach with nearly 20 years of coaching experience, including six years as the defensive coordinator of CFB-playoff-level defenses, is not some sort of desperation gamble. Sure, there were reasonably concerns within his resume, but I don’t think there was a coaching candidate available to Cal that would not have had resume concerns. And the idea that he was a competent hire who would inspire fiscal investment in Cal football was borne out in real life!
Alas, based on the evidence of 10 games, Tosh Lupoi does not provide a base level of competency required of a college football head coach. For that reason, Cal football must replace him as soon as they can afford to do so.
I probably don’t need to convince you of the above. Avi already went into some of the grisly details yesterday, but I’ll show my work as well.
Rather than exhausting you with a litany of painful stats, let’s just go with something holistic. I cite the SP+ analytical rankings often, because they are the most empirically rigorous rankings that exist, tested against Vegas lines every year and coming out ahead. Here is where Cal ranks:
Last among Power 4 teams (you’re welcome, Rutgers). Behind San Jose State. if Cal travelled to Texas to play Rice, the game would be a coin flip. Cal is currently a home underdog to Stanford, the very program who previously held the consensus title for worst power 4 program alongside Rutgers.
You could probably write a lengthy senior thesis about the many, many reasons that Cal is roughly 120th in the country and the worst power conference team in the country. But at some point the reasons are irrelevant: you are what your performance says you are, and Cal is so bad that it represents a very real crisis for the athletic department.
So let’s take as granted that Tosh Lupoi’s 2026 Cal football team has been historically bad. What does that mean for the future?
Bill Radjewski is a college football data analyst who is also a Michigan fan, who has been running numbers about how predictive Year 1 is for future success in a coaching tenure**. The bad news: pretty darn predictive:
Again, this isn’t exactly complex or surprising analysis. But the data is also very clear: coaches that start badly tend to maintain that poor level of performance over time.
There are exceptions of course, but nothing that I see in this data or the specifics of Cal’s situation give me confidence that Lupoi is poised to turn things around. The dataset above is mostly from the pre-portal, pre-NIL era of college football, when coaches had much less control over the roster they inherited in year one. As an obvious example, everybody generally gave Sonny Dykes a mulligan for 2013 because we recognized that he took over a broken roster left behind by Jeff Tedford, and there was no way for him to turn over the roster in one abbreviated off-season.
That very much isn’t the case for Lupoi, who was given the resources to exercise significant oversight of the players he brought in. His defense is almost entirely made up of players that he and his staff identified. He was specifically given a significant cash investment to identify offensive talent to make the most of Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele’s abilities. In spite of being given MORE resources and support than Justin Wilcox ever received, his results are vastly inferior.
No, every piece of objective data says that this year has been uniquely bad, and that Lupoi’s tenure is very likely to continue in this manner for as long as it is allowed to continue.
All of the evidence so far makes me strongly believe that Lupoi’s brief tenure as Cal’s head coach is already an unredeemable failure. Looking purely from the perspective of fielding a winning football team, Cal needs to remove Lupoi from his position as soon as possible.
Can Cal afford to fire Lupoi? Cal did just raise 82 million in donations last year. How much of that has already been spent, and is an extra 20 million hanging around that would allow Cal to move on from the most expensive mistake the athletic department has ever made? Even if Cal does have the money, will the wider campus accept this level of continued spending? Does Rich Lyons have the desire, available cash, and political capital to make a move that has little precedent in the history of college football, let alone in Berkeley?
Ultimately, I am unqualified to answer any of those questions. But the folks who are in a position to influence the decision should approach it from the reality that this is already a sunk cost.
The ‘Sunk Cost Fallacy’ is defined as the tendency to continue with a failed project because of the time, money, and effort you have already expended. Nobody who has sunk resources into achieving something wants to admit that the effort has failed, and so human psychology leads individuals and groups to continue to spend good money chasing bad money.
If Cal determines that they simply don’t have the money to fire Lupoi and turn over the entire football coaching staff, then they need to do it with the clear eyed reality that 2027 under Tosh Lupoi is very likely to look like what we’ve seen in 2026.
Cal’s major donors have stepped up over and over again since the dissolution of the Pac-12 in an ongoing attempt to save Cal football. They may have to step up again.
*Wake Forest’s Jake Dickert, fresh off a richly deserved contract extension, is currently challenging the notion that you have to have competitive NIL funding. He’s a great coach, but my guess is that he struggles to maintain consistent ACC contention without getting more backing from WF donors.
**I recommend that you check out his Bluesky feed, which is full of analysis of what DOES make a good coaching hire, and what kind of intriguing candidates are available for teams in need.




I'm a Maryland grad and a Maryland basketball alum with deep ties to the University of California. Maryland should have fired Mike Locksley more than a year ago and certainly prior to the start of this season..
We (Maryland) made a horrible decision to hire Kevin Willard in 2022 when we had the opportunity to hire the man I pushed hard for the job, Todd Golden. I know Todd quite well from USF and I have good access to Maryland President Darryl Pines who graduated from Berkeley High and the University of California for his B.S. I'll see President Pines Saturday when Maryland football plays at USC. I can't watch Big Game. No fucking way.
Maryland paid a huge price for a bad basketball hire while Florida won a national championship.
California cannot afford to wait. This isn't 2000. Or 2010. Or even 2024. The collegiate sports world is moving at a pace so fast that it defies the imagination.
I despise fUCLA with every inch of my being, but look what the RIGHT HIRE has done for them. California cannot afford to wait.
I will stipulate that I know fuck all about what it takes to be a successful head coach. But I do know a thing or two about what it takes to be a successful leader, having led complex organizations since I was barely out of my teens. I see in Tosh someone who is really, truly, deeply committed to the success of Cal football, but makes the fatal mistake of thinking that by simply applying the attributes of leadership he will succeed.
He works harder than anyone, and leads from the front. He tries to model the concept of accountability. He focuses on culture first and on building the necessary conditions of putting his team in the position of being in danger of succeeding. He is able to inspire allegiance, as seen in his recruiting successes. He may indeed be a great technician of leadership. Maybe even one of the greatest.
But as I wrote in another place, I see him as just that, a technician. The analogy I used was that of what it takes to build a building. You need all manner of engineers and technicians to develop the plans and elements be prepared to assemble to parts into a whole. But you need an architect to pull it all together. Someone who understands the complex dynamics of the whole, and call pull the pieces together. Sadly here is where Tosh fails.
All this to say I have no reason to believe that this will change, and the sunk cost fallacy is precisely what we must avoid. Rich knows this. Go Bears Forever.