I'm a Maryland grad and a Maryland basketball alum with deep ties to the University of California. Maryland should have fired Mike Locksley more than a year ago and certainly prior to the start of this season..
We (Maryland) made a horrible decision to hire Kevin Willard in 2022 when we had the opportunity to hire the man I pushed hard for the job, Todd Golden. I know Todd quite well from USF and I have good access to Maryland President Darryl Pines who graduated from Berkeley High and the University of California for his B.S. I'll see President Pines Saturday when Maryland football plays at USC. I can't watch Big Game. No fucking way.
Maryland paid a huge price for a bad basketball hire while Florida won a national championship.
California cannot afford to wait. This isn't 2000. Or 2010. Or even 2024. The collegiate sports world is moving at a pace so fast that it defies the imagination.
I despise fUCLA with every inch of my being, but look what the RIGHT HIRE has done for them. California cannot afford to wait.
I will stipulate that I know fuck all about what it takes to be a successful head coach. But I do know a thing or two about what it takes to be a successful leader, having led complex organizations since I was barely out of my teens. I see in Tosh someone who is really, truly, deeply committed to the success of Cal football, but makes the fatal mistake of thinking that by simply applying the attributes of leadership he will succeed.
He works harder than anyone, and leads from the front. He tries to model the concept of accountability. He focuses on culture first and on building the necessary conditions of putting his team in the position of being in danger of succeeding. He is able to inspire allegiance, as seen in his recruiting successes. He may indeed be a great technician of leadership. Maybe even one of the greatest.
But as I wrote in another place, I see him as just that, a technician. The analogy I used was that of what it takes to build a building. You need all manner of engineers and technicians to develop the plans and elements be prepared to assemble to parts into a whole. But you need an architect to pull it all together. Someone who understands the complex dynamics of the whole, and call pull the pieces together. Sadly here is where Tosh fails.
All this to say I have no reason to believe that this will change, and the sunk cost fallacy is precisely what we must avoid. Rich knows this. Go Bears Forever.
Nailed it. I am reminded of the John Wooden quote: “never mistake activity for achievement.”
And I wrote a few weeks back when there was still an attempt to defend against firing based on sunk cost fallacy, I said that was what Robert McNamara argued in the mid 1960s. Guess how that turned out
Appreciate the visualization, Nick. There's often the four year plan in college sports of “lose big, lose close, win close, win big,” but there's actually a fair amount of evidence, at least in football, that a coach’s third year is pretty representative of their typical ceiling. It's been true of our previous three coaches- Tedford went 10-2 while Dykes and Wilcox both went 8-5, high-water marks for all three.
What this means is that, short of a true program rebuild like Madsen’s been working with, a good new coach will provide an immediate upward trajectory. Growing pains can exist in places, but the expectation of immediate results is actually quite reasonable if a coach is to have a successful tenure. I expect this 3 year standard will be abbreviated even further in the NIL era.
All this is to say that hoping a coach will grow into the role or dramatically change between seasons is betting on a pretty slim chance. Tosh has shown no sign of adjusting well, either within games or over the course of the season. Better to roll the dice again instead of sticking with a sinking ship.
The one I key in on is the $82m we raised in donations last year.
If Tosh comes back, that donation figure is going to tank, say to $20m (and I’m being generous).
That’s a $62m drop in potential donations and if you add up the lost revenue from ticket sales next year, it gets worse.
In that light, taking a $20m hit to fire Tosh and hiring someone to give people hope could make the numbers work net-net with better tickets sales and surely is higher donation amount than if Tosh were still the coach.
Take the $ hit, leave the cannoli (empty calories anyway).
Given our schedule next year and the potential departure of so many fans (Including me) I believe that's a real possibility next season and not just for one or two games.
I think it's pretty rare for someone with Tosh’s resume to be THIS incompetent. We all saw the warning signs and have seen poorly-coached teams before. But I don't recall seeing anything like this that can so clearly be hung on the coaching staff. Truly astonishing.
Kinda surprised that we made it to Monday without hearing that Ron has taken over for Big Game.
At the risk of repeating myself, there is definitely a way to actually get this done.
We all agree on the problem: Tosh Lupoi has to go. Watching this program crater into an undisciplined mess after all the offseason momentum—and wasting a quarterback like Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele—has been brutal. Waiting any longer than this coming Saturday against Stanford only prolongs the damage.
The real question nobody is answering is how we actually do it.
Because losing games isn’t legal "cause" to void a contract, Chancellor Rich Lyons, GM Ron Rivera, and the big-money donors are staring at a roughly $14.8 million buyout (80% of Lupoi's remaining deal). We can't just light that cash on fire, and we certainly can't expect burned boosters to blindly write another check after the Lupoi experiment blew up in their faces.
If Lyons and Rivera want to pull the trigger right after the Big Game, they need a ruthless business strategy. Here is the realistic two-part plan to cut the buyout bill and convince our donors to fund a real hire:
Part 1: How Cal Cuts the Buyout Bill
Audit for Quiet Leverage: Before firing him, UC legal counsel should quietly audit Lupoi’s staff management and compliance record for any minor infractions. You don’t sue him "for cause"—you use those slips behind closed doors to pressure his agent into accepting a discounted settlement rather than risking public embarrassment.
Offer a Face-Saving "Step Down": As a Bay Area native and Cal alum, a messy public firing ruins Lupoi’s future career. Cal should offer a mutual "stepping down" announcement in exchange for knocking that 80% guarantee down to 50%–60%—or taking an immediate $9M–$10M lump-sum check funded by boosters.
Enforce the Mitigation Clause: Lupoi’s contract legally requires him to seek comparable work, with every dollar he makes deducted from what Cal owes him. Cal must enforce strict quarterly job-search audits so he can’t sit on a beach or take a fake $50k "analyst" gig to double-dip on our dime.
Strip His Autonomy: If Lupoi resists a discount, Ron Rivera should immediately exercise his GM authority to mandate staff changes and strip Lupoi’s play-calling and personnel control. Once a head coach is reduced to a figurehead, his agent usually calls to negotiate an exit.
Part 2: Winning Back Burned Boosters
Big-money donors feel burned after bankrolling a massive transfer class and assistant pool only to watch a first-time head coach drown. To get them to open their checkbooks again on Sunday morning, Lyons and Rivera must pitch a proven turnaround blueprint modeled on what Curt Cignetti did at Indiana and what UCLA pursued:
No More "On-the-Job Training": Guarantee donors that the search is strictly limited to sitting or proven head coaches with a documented track record of winning. No more splashy recruiters or first-time coordinators learning how to be a head coach at Cal's expense.
The "Plug-and-Play" Roster Pitch: Sell donors on the modern portal reality. Hiring an established head coach with a winning system—like Indiana did with Cignetti—means he brings proven coordinators and immediate starter-level talent with him. That saves our current roster before the portal window opens rather than starting another four-year rebuild.
Separate the Buyout from the War Chest: Give donors a clean, transparent ledger. Separate the one-time buyout settlement from the ongoing NIL and assistant pool so boosters know their new money is building a winner, not just paying off a mistake.
If Lyons and Rivera put this exact plan in front of our biggest donors right after the Stanford game, we can turn a $14.8M disaster into a clean reset before it's too late.
This just has to happen as the alternative of allowing Lupoi to continue this embarrassment makes absolutely no sense. Get somebody who knows college football to lead the search and ensure whatever person is chosen to be tge next HC has the best chance possible to succeed.
Thoughtful post as always. I’d argue that Lupoi’s on field results have torched his career more so than a firing would. The firing is inevitable at this point, it’s simply an issue of Rich Lyons’ tolerance for pain.
95% there with you on this...where I hold back my 5% is on that we need to follow the Cignetti Model. EVERYONE in college football who is disappointed right now (guessing 2/3 of fan bases to one degree or another) are saying this. To my mind it's like saying we just need to do what Apple does to form a great company. So easy to say, so unlikely to happen for the simple reason that there are so few truly transformational leaders in this world...you can count them on one hand. So yes to all the great negotiating concepts, but let's not dwell on the idea we can do Cignetti 2.0...a worthy objective , but I fear it will lead to more disappointment.
I'm so sad. We have a really bad program, we are a football patsy for other ACC schools, we have an unready HC, we have doubts about RR, and now the program has a meme of how to run a fake FG play that goes for a pick 6. BTW, that play will forever be known as “The Tosh”. 2027 will be another full teardown and rebuild, so we are starting over. Very distressing…
The sunk cost fallacy is exactly what people have been applying to this scenario for a while. Recent results confirm the urgency of ditching Lupoi IMMEDIATELY. The chancellor is/was a business professor, so fortunately he knows the concept. Unlike past chancellors, he believes success in football is important. What Nick did not mention is that Rivera also needs to go.
I don’t think there’s a lot of transparency into exactly how the HC decision was made and who made it. You’d think the GM and Chancellor had a major hand in making it, but with the amount of money involved I would not be surprised if the money guys at least had a hand in it. The whole point here being that a do over should include people or someone who understands the college game as played today with all the NIL and portal issues associated with building a winning program. Not easy and not a game for amateurs!
I believe Ron's biggest responsibility was getting the money. And behind closed doors, the money has influence. This has been a common theory on this site. And considering the news stories and gossip/leaks about Ron wanting to be the coach originally and him and Tosh being at odds throughout, that could be Ron's camp signalling "this wasn't actually my decision".
I get why Ron would want to signal that after such a disastrous hire, but I simply don’t believe that his hands were tied. Sure, donor preference is a strong factor. But if donors make decisions what’s the point of his role.
It's a secretive gray area, but an analogy would be a meddling NFL owner forcing a GM's hand, or a board of directors forcing a big decision on a CEO. They have to own the decision and be the face of it. That's not to say they don't have other important responsibilities..
If Ron really wanted the head coaching job, I wonder why we wouldn’t give it to him? We could surround him with a good recruiting staff if that was a concern. I was puzzled by the article’s claim that he wanted the job.
The theory around here is that Ron’s hand was “forced” by donors who wanted Lupoi installed. Whether that’s true or not, who knows. If we fire Lupoi I think it becomes almost a certainty that Ron is the replacement HC, primarily out of financial considerations.
I for one am grateful for the decision to run "The Tosh" fake field goal play. What a demonstration of how pathetic our program and team have become. I really do not understand how you can be this bad, in today's environment where there are lots of good to great coaches and players. I have also come to believe that our players are not that good. If Tosh's main attribute is talent acquisition, I think he has failed there as well.
The play calling has been atrocious, but the execution has been horrible as well. And, again, why is Ron wearing a headset and patrolling the sidelines? I understand he was interested in the Arizona Cardinals HC vacancy as well as our own. He's not fit for the GM role.
Humiliation can be the impetus to get things right this time. It is my hope that those with the money decision making authority get to our rebuild now, and not later.
The Athletic article had a sentence in it that shook me to my core: Ron wanted the head coach position. I think we need to accept the likelihood that he takes the reins in the scenario in which Lupoi is fired.
Nick is spot on like he usually is [and writes out loud what many of us have been saying for weeks now, since at least the Wake Forest blowout last month]:
> Can Cal afford to fire Lupoi? Cal did just raise 82 million in donations last year. How much of that has already been spent, and is an extra 20 million hanging around that would allow Cal to move on from the most expensive mistake the athletic department has ever made? Even if Cal does have the money, will the wider campus accept this level of continued spending? Does Rich Lyons have the desire, available cash, and political capital to make a move that has little precedent in the history of college football, let alone in Berkeley?
> Ultimately, I am unqualified to answer any of those questions. But the folks who are in a position to influence the decision should approach it from the reality that this is already a sunk cost.
> The ‘Sunk Cost Fallacy’ is defined as the tendency to continue with a failed project because of the time, money, and effort you have already expended. Nobody who has sunk resources into achieving something wants to admit that the effort has failed, and so human psychology leads individuals and groups to continue to spend good money chasing bad money.
> If Cal determines that they simply don’t have the money to fire Lupoi and turn over the entire football coaching staff, then they need to do it with the clear eyed reality that 2027 under Tosh Lupoi is very likely to look like what we’ve seen in 2026.
> Cal’s major donors have stepped up over and over again since the dissolution of the Pac-12 in an ongoing attempt to save Cal football. They may have to step up again.
Agreed - always get a chuckle out of how various fans on W4C express similar thoughts and get ridiculed but then the same news/conclusions show up in an article.
Though folks have called for RR to be fired too, no one has raised the issue of replacing Lupoi if RR remains as GM. Not so much the competence to hire the right person, but more the reputation RR now has trolling the sideline with a headset. What impression does that leave for prospective Lupoi replacement and their willingness to step into an environment where the GM had major conflict with the prior HC and micromanaged the situation?
Adding to the point. Whatever is broken ain’t going to be fixed by our GM wearing a headset but will certainly project an even deeper level of dysfunction within the program. Then again, I guess RR wasn’t too concerned about that given his comments on KNBR.
I don’t dispute the premise that hiring Lupoi was a reasonable decision even if he was a first time HC. JW was a first time HC. Lupoi came from a higher coaching pedigree with Alabama and Oregon. Also to the point that Nick makes regarding trajectory based on first year: JW was 5-7 and excluding 2020, averaged 5.875 wins over the rest of his tenure.
I'm a Maryland grad and a Maryland basketball alum with deep ties to the University of California. Maryland should have fired Mike Locksley more than a year ago and certainly prior to the start of this season..
We (Maryland) made a horrible decision to hire Kevin Willard in 2022 when we had the opportunity to hire the man I pushed hard for the job, Todd Golden. I know Todd quite well from USF and I have good access to Maryland President Darryl Pines who graduated from Berkeley High and the University of California for his B.S. I'll see President Pines Saturday when Maryland football plays at USC. I can't watch Big Game. No fucking way.
Maryland paid a huge price for a bad basketball hire while Florida won a national championship.
California cannot afford to wait. This isn't 2000. Or 2010. Or even 2024. The collegiate sports world is moving at a pace so fast that it defies the imagination.
I despise fUCLA with every inch of my being, but look what the RIGHT HIRE has done for them. California cannot afford to wait.
I will stipulate that I know fuck all about what it takes to be a successful head coach. But I do know a thing or two about what it takes to be a successful leader, having led complex organizations since I was barely out of my teens. I see in Tosh someone who is really, truly, deeply committed to the success of Cal football, but makes the fatal mistake of thinking that by simply applying the attributes of leadership he will succeed.
He works harder than anyone, and leads from the front. He tries to model the concept of accountability. He focuses on culture first and on building the necessary conditions of putting his team in the position of being in danger of succeeding. He is able to inspire allegiance, as seen in his recruiting successes. He may indeed be a great technician of leadership. Maybe even one of the greatest.
But as I wrote in another place, I see him as just that, a technician. The analogy I used was that of what it takes to build a building. You need all manner of engineers and technicians to develop the plans and elements be prepared to assemble to parts into a whole. But you need an architect to pull it all together. Someone who understands the complex dynamics of the whole, and call pull the pieces together. Sadly here is where Tosh fails.
All this to say I have no reason to believe that this will change, and the sunk cost fallacy is precisely what we must avoid. Rich knows this. Go Bears Forever.
The “How he works” part of his performance review may be second to none.
He is failing spectacularly at the “what he works” part of his coaching performance.
Cal just can’t afford to continue with this Tosh experiment.
Nailed it. I am reminded of the John Wooden quote: “never mistake activity for achievement.”
And I wrote a few weeks back when there was still an attempt to defend against firing based on sunk cost fallacy, I said that was what Robert McNamara argued in the mid 1960s. Guess how that turned out
A great summation of the situation.
Appreciate the visualization, Nick. There's often the four year plan in college sports of “lose big, lose close, win close, win big,” but there's actually a fair amount of evidence, at least in football, that a coach’s third year is pretty representative of their typical ceiling. It's been true of our previous three coaches- Tedford went 10-2 while Dykes and Wilcox both went 8-5, high-water marks for all three.
What this means is that, short of a true program rebuild like Madsen’s been working with, a good new coach will provide an immediate upward trajectory. Growing pains can exist in places, but the expectation of immediate results is actually quite reasonable if a coach is to have a successful tenure. I expect this 3 year standard will be abbreviated even further in the NIL era.
All this is to say that hoping a coach will grow into the role or dramatically change between seasons is betting on a pretty slim chance. Tosh has shown no sign of adjusting well, either within games or over the course of the season. Better to roll the dice again instead of sticking with a sinking ship.
Good article and lays out some important facts.
The one I key in on is the $82m we raised in donations last year.
If Tosh comes back, that donation figure is going to tank, say to $20m (and I’m being generous).
That’s a $62m drop in potential donations and if you add up the lost revenue from ticket sales next year, it gets worse.
In that light, taking a $20m hit to fire Tosh and hiring someone to give people hope could make the numbers work net-net with better tickets sales and surely is higher donation amount than if Tosh were still the coach.
Take the $ hit, leave the cannoli (empty calories anyway).
Can you imagine when attendance is under 25,000 per game?
Given our schedule next year and the potential departure of so many fans (Including me) I believe that's a real possibility next season and not just for one or two games.
I think it's pretty rare for someone with Tosh’s resume to be THIS incompetent. We all saw the warning signs and have seen poorly-coached teams before. But I don't recall seeing anything like this that can so clearly be hung on the coaching staff. Truly astonishing.
Kinda surprised that we made it to Monday without hearing that Ron has taken over for Big Game.
At the risk of repeating myself, there is definitely a way to actually get this done.
We all agree on the problem: Tosh Lupoi has to go. Watching this program crater into an undisciplined mess after all the offseason momentum—and wasting a quarterback like Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele—has been brutal. Waiting any longer than this coming Saturday against Stanford only prolongs the damage.
The real question nobody is answering is how we actually do it.
Because losing games isn’t legal "cause" to void a contract, Chancellor Rich Lyons, GM Ron Rivera, and the big-money donors are staring at a roughly $14.8 million buyout (80% of Lupoi's remaining deal). We can't just light that cash on fire, and we certainly can't expect burned boosters to blindly write another check after the Lupoi experiment blew up in their faces.
If Lyons and Rivera want to pull the trigger right after the Big Game, they need a ruthless business strategy. Here is the realistic two-part plan to cut the buyout bill and convince our donors to fund a real hire:
Part 1: How Cal Cuts the Buyout Bill
Audit for Quiet Leverage: Before firing him, UC legal counsel should quietly audit Lupoi’s staff management and compliance record for any minor infractions. You don’t sue him "for cause"—you use those slips behind closed doors to pressure his agent into accepting a discounted settlement rather than risking public embarrassment.
Offer a Face-Saving "Step Down": As a Bay Area native and Cal alum, a messy public firing ruins Lupoi’s future career. Cal should offer a mutual "stepping down" announcement in exchange for knocking that 80% guarantee down to 50%–60%—or taking an immediate $9M–$10M lump-sum check funded by boosters.
Enforce the Mitigation Clause: Lupoi’s contract legally requires him to seek comparable work, with every dollar he makes deducted from what Cal owes him. Cal must enforce strict quarterly job-search audits so he can’t sit on a beach or take a fake $50k "analyst" gig to double-dip on our dime.
Strip His Autonomy: If Lupoi resists a discount, Ron Rivera should immediately exercise his GM authority to mandate staff changes and strip Lupoi’s play-calling and personnel control. Once a head coach is reduced to a figurehead, his agent usually calls to negotiate an exit.
Part 2: Winning Back Burned Boosters
Big-money donors feel burned after bankrolling a massive transfer class and assistant pool only to watch a first-time head coach drown. To get them to open their checkbooks again on Sunday morning, Lyons and Rivera must pitch a proven turnaround blueprint modeled on what Curt Cignetti did at Indiana and what UCLA pursued:
No More "On-the-Job Training": Guarantee donors that the search is strictly limited to sitting or proven head coaches with a documented track record of winning. No more splashy recruiters or first-time coordinators learning how to be a head coach at Cal's expense.
The "Plug-and-Play" Roster Pitch: Sell donors on the modern portal reality. Hiring an established head coach with a winning system—like Indiana did with Cignetti—means he brings proven coordinators and immediate starter-level talent with him. That saves our current roster before the portal window opens rather than starting another four-year rebuild.
Separate the Buyout from the War Chest: Give donors a clean, transparent ledger. Separate the one-time buyout settlement from the ongoing NIL and assistant pool so boosters know their new money is building a winner, not just paying off a mistake.
If Lyons and Rivera put this exact plan in front of our biggest donors right after the Stanford game, we can turn a $14.8M disaster into a clean reset before it's too late.
This just has to happen as the alternative of allowing Lupoi to continue this embarrassment makes absolutely no sense. Get somebody who knows college football to lead the search and ensure whatever person is chosen to be tge next HC has the best chance possible to succeed.
Thoughtful post as always. I’d argue that Lupoi’s on field results have torched his career more so than a firing would. The firing is inevitable at this point, it’s simply an issue of Rich Lyons’ tolerance for pain.
95% there with you on this...where I hold back my 5% is on that we need to follow the Cignetti Model. EVERYONE in college football who is disappointed right now (guessing 2/3 of fan bases to one degree or another) are saying this. To my mind it's like saying we just need to do what Apple does to form a great company. So easy to say, so unlikely to happen for the simple reason that there are so few truly transformational leaders in this world...you can count them on one hand. So yes to all the great negotiating concepts, but let's not dwell on the idea we can do Cignetti 2.0...a worthy objective , but I fear it will lead to more disappointment.
I think there is an appetite from our alumni base to contribute to a buyout. Call it “Coach Search Fund” and raise it on GoFundMe.
This will also show the public our will for immediate change in addition to helping to subsidize this painful buyout.
Maybe we can get him to settle. Instead of money, for 5 years we name it Tosh Lupoi Stadium, with his face as the logo in the middle of the field.
Sort of like in Seinfeld when Kramer settled his lawsuit with Big Tobacco by becoming the new Marlboro Man on billboards.
Maybe Tosh would pay to NOT have the stadium named after him?
Very funny.
I'm so sad. We have a really bad program, we are a football patsy for other ACC schools, we have an unready HC, we have doubts about RR, and now the program has a meme of how to run a fake FG play that goes for a pick 6. BTW, that play will forever be known as “The Tosh”. 2027 will be another full teardown and rebuild, so we are starting over. Very distressing…
The sunk cost fallacy is exactly what people have been applying to this scenario for a while. Recent results confirm the urgency of ditching Lupoi IMMEDIATELY. The chancellor is/was a business professor, so fortunately he knows the concept. Unlike past chancellors, he believes success in football is important. What Nick did not mention is that Rivera also needs to go.
Don’t throw good money after bad money.
Maybe we should have had a stop out clause for Tosh’s contract after he loses so many games.
If it's true the big donors are the ones who pushed for Tosh (and Ron’s hands were tied), here's hoping they are willing to own up to their mistake..
I don’t think there’s a lot of transparency into exactly how the HC decision was made and who made it. You’d think the GM and Chancellor had a major hand in making it, but with the amount of money involved I would not be surprised if the money guys at least had a hand in it. The whole point here being that a do over should include people or someone who understands the college game as played today with all the NIL and portal issues associated with building a winning program. Not easy and not a game for amateurs!
I don’t see how that would ever be true. Isn’t the coaching hire one of the GM’s most important responsibilities?
I believe Ron's biggest responsibility was getting the money. And behind closed doors, the money has influence. This has been a common theory on this site. And considering the news stories and gossip/leaks about Ron wanting to be the coach originally and him and Tosh being at odds throughout, that could be Ron's camp signalling "this wasn't actually my decision".
I get why Ron would want to signal that after such a disastrous hire, but I simply don’t believe that his hands were tied. Sure, donor preference is a strong factor. But if donors make decisions what’s the point of his role.
It's a secretive gray area, but an analogy would be a meddling NFL owner forcing a GM's hand, or a board of directors forcing a big decision on a CEO. They have to own the decision and be the face of it. That's not to say they don't have other important responsibilities..
If Ron really wanted the head coaching job, I wonder why we wouldn’t give it to him? We could surround him with a good recruiting staff if that was a concern. I was puzzled by the article’s claim that he wanted the job.
The theory around here is that Ron’s hand was “forced” by donors who wanted Lupoi installed. Whether that’s true or not, who knows. If we fire Lupoi I think it becomes almost a certainty that Ron is the replacement HC, primarily out of financial considerations.
If we make another hire let’s get someone from a winning program and can bring over a bunch of players, especially linemen
I for one am grateful for the decision to run "The Tosh" fake field goal play. What a demonstration of how pathetic our program and team have become. I really do not understand how you can be this bad, in today's environment where there are lots of good to great coaches and players. I have also come to believe that our players are not that good. If Tosh's main attribute is talent acquisition, I think he has failed there as well.
The play calling has been atrocious, but the execution has been horrible as well. And, again, why is Ron wearing a headset and patrolling the sidelines? I understand he was interested in the Arizona Cardinals HC vacancy as well as our own. He's not fit for the GM role.
Humiliation can be the impetus to get things right this time. It is my hope that those with the money decision making authority get to our rebuild now, and not later.
The Athletic article had a sentence in it that shook me to my core: Ron wanted the head coach position. I think we need to accept the likelihood that he takes the reins in the scenario in which Lupoi is fired.
Nick is spot on like he usually is [and writes out loud what many of us have been saying for weeks now, since at least the Wake Forest blowout last month]:
> Can Cal afford to fire Lupoi? Cal did just raise 82 million in donations last year. How much of that has already been spent, and is an extra 20 million hanging around that would allow Cal to move on from the most expensive mistake the athletic department has ever made? Even if Cal does have the money, will the wider campus accept this level of continued spending? Does Rich Lyons have the desire, available cash, and political capital to make a move that has little precedent in the history of college football, let alone in Berkeley?
> Ultimately, I am unqualified to answer any of those questions. But the folks who are in a position to influence the decision should approach it from the reality that this is already a sunk cost.
> The ‘Sunk Cost Fallacy’ is defined as the tendency to continue with a failed project because of the time, money, and effort you have already expended. Nobody who has sunk resources into achieving something wants to admit that the effort has failed, and so human psychology leads individuals and groups to continue to spend good money chasing bad money.
> If Cal determines that they simply don’t have the money to fire Lupoi and turn over the entire football coaching staff, then they need to do it with the clear eyed reality that 2027 under Tosh Lupoi is very likely to look like what we’ve seen in 2026.
> Cal’s major donors have stepped up over and over again since the dissolution of the Pac-12 in an ongoing attempt to save Cal football. They may have to step up again.
https://www.reddit.com/r/calfootball/comments/1xxyrwl/comment/19sqk8j9ie7wg/
Agreed - always get a chuckle out of how various fans on W4C express similar thoughts and get ridiculed but then the same news/conclusions show up in an article.
Yep…
Though folks have called for RR to be fired too, no one has raised the issue of replacing Lupoi if RR remains as GM. Not so much the competence to hire the right person, but more the reputation RR now has trolling the sideline with a headset. What impression does that leave for prospective Lupoi replacement and their willingness to step into an environment where the GM had major conflict with the prior HC and micromanaged the situation?
Adding to the point. Whatever is broken ain’t going to be fixed by our GM wearing a headset but will certainly project an even deeper level of dysfunction within the program. Then again, I guess RR wasn’t too concerned about that given his comments on KNBR.
I don’t dispute the premise that hiring Lupoi was a reasonable decision even if he was a first time HC. JW was a first time HC. Lupoi came from a higher coaching pedigree with Alabama and Oregon. Also to the point that Nick makes regarding trajectory based on first year: JW was 5-7 and excluding 2020, averaged 5.875 wins over the rest of his tenure.